· 15 items
City Council, Thursday, November 5
On the episode: Council tables SEDA indefinitely; water and sewer rate process begins
This episode was produced with AI from the public recordings of the week's meetings. Links to the sources are in the show notes.
What happened
City Council Thursday, November 5
15 items
Approval of the agenda
The council approved the day's agenda after the clerk read changes: the environmental findings for consent item 2B (Chaffee Zoo lease) were replaced with findings that rely on the 2011 environmental impact report for the Roeding Regional Park and Fresno Chaffee Zoo master plans; items 2F (agricultural land lease at the regional wastewater plant) and 2I (a $15 million federal Section 108 loan application for an affordable housing loan pool, per the agenda) were tabled to the November 12, 2026 meeting by Miguel Arias (Councilmember, District 3); and items 2J (9-1-1 call center) and 2L (water and wastewater rate process) were moved to contested consent by Miguel Arias (Councilmember, District 3). 00:26:01
- Motion to approve the agenda as changed, seconded by Nelson Esparza (Councilmember, District 7; Council President) (the maker isn't identified in the transcript); Mike Karbassi (Councilmember, District 2) didn't answer the roll. Result: passed, 6-0. 00:31:11
Proclamation: Athletic Hall of Fame Day
The council and mayor proclaimed November 5, 2026 Fresno Athletic Hall of Fame Day, honoring the Hall of Fame and its 2026 inductees. 00:31:17
Proclamation: Secret War Veterans Day
The council and mayor proclaimed November 5, 2026 Secret War Veterans Day, honoring the Special Guerrilla Units and the Lao Veterans of America, Hmong veterans who fought alongside the U.S. in Laos from 1961 to 1975. 00:41:14
Proclamation: Nurse Practitioners Week
The council and mayor recognized the week of November 8 through 14, 2026 as Nurse Practitioners Week, honoring nurse practitioners. 00:52:07
Proclamation: Sikh Heritage Month
The council and mayor proclaimed November 2026 Sikh Heritage Month in Fresno, honoring the Sikh community. 01:02:10
Councilmember reports and comments
Councilmembers reported on district events and announced the Veterans Day Parade on November 11. 01:12:02
- Brandon Vang (Councilmember, District 5) reported attending trunk-or-treat events at several District 5 sites and thanked his staff for organizing them 01:12:24
- Brandon Vang (Councilmember, District 5) described attending a touring theater performance at Sunnyside High about suicide prevention 01:13:29
- A councilmember announced free transportation to the Veterans Day Parade from three pickup spots around town 01:16:21
- A councilmember invited residents to the Central Valley Veterans Day Parade on November 11, starting at 11:11 a.m. 01:19:09
- A councilmember asked that the meeting adjourn in honor of a late labor and civil rights leader 01:19:09
Consent calendar Item 2
Parks and treesWaterAirports and aviation
The council approved the routine consent items in one vote, minus items tabled (2F, 2I) and pulled for discussion (2J, 2L). They include a Chaffee Zoo lease amendment for a parking lot inside Roeding Park, airport marketing, water service replacement and software contracts, police fee changes, and a district tax annexation hearing date. No one spoke during the consent public comment period. 01:19:54
- Motion to approve the consent calendar minus the contested items (maker and second not identified in the transcript); Tyler Maxwell (Councilmember, District 4; Council Vice President) didn't answer the roll. Result: passed, 6-0. 01:21:24
Eminent domain: easements at 3811 North Orchard Street for Blackstone Shields-Dakota project Item 1
Streets and public worksAffordable housingBiking and walking
A resolution of necessity authorizing eminent domain to acquire a permanent street easement, a permanent pedestrian easement, and a temporary construction easement on a privately owned parcel at 3811 North Orchard Street (APN 436-292-07) in District 4, for the Blackstone Shields-Dakota Affordable Housing and Sustainable Communities street and walkway improvements. The agenda says it requires five affirmative votes and is subject to the mayor's veto. 01:21:35
- A councilmember moved to approve the categorical exemption finding and the resolution of necessity; seconded (seconder not identified); the chair said the vice president, Tyler Maxwell (Councilmember, District 4; Council Vice President), was not there. Result: passed, 6-0. 01:27:09
- Nelson Esparza (Councilmember, District 7; Council President) noted the vice president was not present and opened public comment without a staff presentation 01:21:26
Office zone text amendment to allow single-family homes and duplexes Item 1
Zoning and plansHousing supply
Text Amendment P26-02730 amends Fresno Municipal Code Section 15-1302 to keep the city in line with its Housing Element and allow more housing types on vacant or underutilized parcels zoned Office. Staff described it as a cleanup of last year's change: single-family attached, single-family detached and duplex homes would be listed as allowed uses, built at a minimum density of 12 units per acre with RS5 single-family development standards (setbacks, facades, landscaping, parking). The agenda lists a CEQA exemption finding and the bill for introduction. 01:27:16
- Motion to approve the CEQA finding and introduce the bill, seconded (the transcript doesn't clearly identify the maker or seconder); the clerk announced it as seven to zero, though no reply from Tyler Maxwell (Councilmember, District 4; Council Vice President) was recorded on the roll. Result: passed, 7-0. 01:39:47
- A councilmember described the item as an update to the text amendment the council approved previously 01:27:43
- Mike Karbassi (Councilmember, District 2) asked whether lower-density single-family homes could be built on office-zoned land under the change 01:29:59
- City staff answered that single-family homes would be allowed but at the RM1 minimum density of 12 units per acre, not RS5 density 01:30:58
- Mike Karbassi (Councilmember, District 2) argued no one is building offices anymore and questioned why any housing type would be excluded 01:31:45
- City staff explained the change is a cleanup because single-family uses were left out of the use tables when the ordinance was adopted a year earlier 01:31:56
- Mike Karbassi (Councilmember, District 2) asked whether allowing RS5 density would conflict with state law, which staff confirmed 01:34:06
- City staff said owners could build single-family attached, detached or duplex homes as long as they meet the 12-unit-per-acre minimum 01:35:18
- Annalisa Perea (Councilmember, District 1) thanked staff and called the change a minor clarification of what the council intended last year 01:35:37
- A councilmember said he believed he had voted against the original text amendment 01:36:33
- City staff said the change lets units be laid out on separate lots for a neighborhood feel rather than stacked in multifamily buildings 01:37:18
- City staff said the RS5 district allows a minimum lot size of 2,500 square feet with an enhanced streetscape 01:38:21
- City staff said the change would not apply at the northeast corner of Jensen and Temperance, which is outside city limits and not zoned office 01:39:01
- A councilmember said he would watch the change closely because most eligible sites are in Northeast Fresno 01:39:07
Starting the Prop 218 process for water and wastewater rate increases Item 2-L
WaterTaxes and fees
The council directed staff to start the Proposition 218 process for proposed increases to water and wastewater rates. The agenda sets the public hearing for December 29, 2026 at 9:00 a.m. Staff said this is a five-year rate plan starting January 1, 2027 and running through June 30, 2031, that about 180,000 protest notices will go out, and that the increases can be stopped only if a majority of customers file protests. Councilmembers argued about holding the final hearing at a special meeting after Christmas, before new councilmembers take office. 01:40:35
- Brandon Vang (Councilmember, District 5) moved to amend the item to add Punjabi to the notices and to set the rate hearing for the next regular council meeting after the 45-day period instead of December 29. Result: no action. 02:23:29
- Mike Karbassi (Councilmember, District 2) moved to approve the staff recommendation: start the Prop 218 process and set the rate hearing for December 29, 2026 at 9:00 a.m. Result: passed, 5-2. No: Miguel Arias (Councilmember, District 3), Brandon Vang (Councilmember, District 5). 02:24:08Ayes: Nelson Esparza, Tyler Maxwell, Annalisa Perea, Mike Karbassi, Nick Richardson. Noes: Miguel Arias, Brandon Vang. Moved by Mike Karbassi, seconded by Tyler Maxwell. From the clerk's record
- A councilmember raised concern that the city can't help residents move off sprinklers in city-controlled parkway strips and asked whether the rates account for that 01:40:59
- City staff said utilities staff are working with the vice president's office on the legal requirements for a program to convert parkway strips 01:41:45
- City staff committed to having a parkway program framework by the time of the Prop 218 hearing 01:42:31
- A councilmember said that if election results hold he will not be on the council for the December 29 hearing 01:43:02
- A councilmember said it had been suggested the city borrow nearly $100 million from the utility fund for SEDA sewer lines, and asked what projects would be delayed 01:44:04
- City staff disputed that, saying the city would issue bonds specifically for a SEDA trunk sewer, repaid by a new trunk sewer fee 01:45:22
- The city manager argued no listed utility project would be dropped because those projects take years and design work could continue 01:46:34
- A councilmember questioned how the city can borrow for a new SEDA line when it says it lacks money to replace aging lines before they burst 01:47:49
- City staff said the sewer rate plan uses debt financing to keep rates low so aging-line projects can get done 01:48:22
- The city manager said there are no outstanding bonds on the sewer fund; the water fund carries a low- or no-interest state loan tied to Recharge Fresno 01:49:15
- City staff confirmed that no settlement money from the Shell well-contamination case has been used to reimburse the utility for past expenses 01:49:58
- The city manager said the settlement was meant to rehabilitate or replace contaminated wells and cover ten years of operations going forward, not past costs 01:50:15
- A councilmember said his understanding was that the settlement would offset costs the city had already spent, and asked legal counsel to report back 01:50:57
- A councilmember asked for the total of all water and wastewater reserve accounts 01:54:11
- The city manager said reserves aren't reported as a single total because some are restricted, and promised to provide the figures; said interest stays in the reserve accounts 01:54:27
- City staff estimated that 90 to 95 percent of utility customers are inside the city, with the rest in county islands 01:56:54
- A councilmember noted water rates last rose in 2018 after 2015 approval, and wastewater rates in 2010 after 2007 approval 01:56:58
- City staff explained that an adopted five-year schedule is applied automatically each year, and the council could only lower the rates 02:03:02
- City staff said that without a new plan after June 30, 2031, rates would stay at the final step 02:04:13
- The city manager said staff found a structural inequity between rate classes that is inconsistent with Prop 218, and that delay exposes the city to risk 02:04:55
- A councilmember noted that by January 7 three new councilmembers will be seated, and called for transparency on a five-year increase 02:05:51
- City staff said about 180,000 protest cards and notices will be mailed 02:07:34
- A councilmember asked whether Fresno customers had ever returned a majority protest under Prop 218; staff answered they had not 02:08:48
- A councilmember objected to holding the rate hearing at a special meeting right after Christmas, when few people follow city business 02:09:14
- City staff said notices are printed in English, with instructions for getting translations in other languages 02:11:36
- The city manager said the schedule was laid out at an earlier meeting, nine community meetings are planned, and rate increases have been discussed publicly for two to three years 02:12:45
- A councilmember proposed amendments to add Punjabi to the notices and to move the hearing to the next regular meeting after the 45-day period, which he put at January 7, 2027 02:16:43
- A councilmember called the discussion redundant and said the vote only starts the process for community input 02:18:12
- A councilmember moved to approve the staff recommendation 02:18:58
- A councilmember supported moving final adoption to the regular January meeting, noting several members may be gone by then 02:19:16
- A councilmember argued it's too much to ask new councilmembers to make this decision at their first meeting 02:21:00
- A councilmember asked staff to confirm that yearly increases would be under $3 and that water rates in fiscal 2031 would still be below Clovis's current rates; staff said yes 02:22:03
- The city manager said the hearing could not be at the first January meeting because notices are already printed and would have to be reprinted; a cost of about $300,000 was given 02:22:34
- A councilmember asked whether rates would drop next fiscal year; the reply in the same turn was that wastewater rates would go down $0.95 02:23:07
Furniture and phone-system support for the new police 9-1-1 call center Item 2-J
PolicingHistoric preservation
Actions for the Police Department's new 9-1-1 call center at 1515 El Dorado Street (District 3), per the agenda: a cooperative purchase of console furniture from Russ Bassett Corporation, not to exceed $734,387.54; a finding that AT&T is uniquely qualified to provide extended warranty support for the existing 9-1-1 system through March 5, 2027, not to exceed $99,695.62; and an appropriation of $904,500, which requires five votes. Discussion focused on what happens to the old dispatch building. 02:24:28
- Motion to approve (spoken at the end of a turn labeled the city manager); the clerk identified the second as the vice president, Tyler Maxwell (Councilmember, District 4; Council Vice President); Annalisa Perea (Councilmember, District 1) had left the meeting. Result: passed, 6-0. 02:25:57Ayes: Nelson Esparza, Tyler Maxwell, Mike Karbassi, Miguel Arias, Brandon Vang, Nick Richardson. Absent: Annalisa Perea. Moved by Miguel Arias, seconded by Tyler Maxwell. From the clerk's record
- A councilmember asked the city manager to state on the record the plans for the building that will be vacated by 9-1-1 dispatch 02:24:35
- The city manager said the old police headquarters building, built in 1959, is functionally obsolete and the city plans to demolish it after reviewing its historical aspects and relocating critical infrastructure 02:25:04
- The city manager said the city would go to the historic preservation commission if required 02:25:41
Closed session Item 5
Public employeesLawsuits and settlementsAppointments and leadership
The council met privately on labor negotiations with the city's employee unions and unrepresented employees, two existing lawsuits against the city, five matters of anticipated litigation, and performance evaluations of the City Clerk and City Attorney. The city attorney said there may be reportable items; no report appears in the recording. 02:33:21
Workshop: Financially Sustainable Cities Item 4-A
BudgetsZoning and plans
A workshop sponsored by Miguel Arias (Councilmember, District 3), given remotely by a presenter from the firm Urban3, on measuring property value and tax revenue per acre and the long-term costs of infrastructure. The aim was to weigh how growth patterns affect city finances, ahead of the scheduled vote on the Southeast Development Area. The chair capped it at thirty minutes. No action was taken. 04:46:00
▶ Hear it A member says the city's finances disprove the warning about growth costs · 0:37
- A guest presenter argued that a city should be viewed like a corporation that can't spend beyond its revenues 04:48:45
- A guest presenter cited an Asheville downtown building that grew from $300,000 to $11 million in value, contrasting it with a far larger Walmart site 04:49:45
- A guest presenter said Omaha's past development created infrastructure needing about $800 million a year in spending, versus roughly $400 million spent, a structural deficit 05:03:21
- A guest presenter argued infill development can be more productive than outward growth 05:07:31
- Mike Karbassi (Councilmember, District 2) criticized the presentation, citing record city reserves, the highest credit rating in city history, and balanced budgets 05:09:46
- A guest presenter acknowledged not knowing Fresno's credit rating 05:10:07
- A councilmember tied the workshop to the coming debate over growing east and taking on debt for SEDA, noting staff and outside business interests had sent their own financial reports 05:10:30
Southeast Development Area (SEDA) Specific Plan tabled indefinitely Item 1
Zoning and plans
The hearing would have considered certifying the final environmental impact report (SCH No. 2022020486) and adopting the Southeast Development Area Specific Plan, with related General Plan map and text changes, for about 9,000 acres in southeast and east Fresno. Instead, the council voted to table the item indefinitely before any staff presentation or public comment, so none of those actions were taken. Earlier in the day the council discussed bond financing for a SEDA sewer trunk line. 07:46:07
- A councilmember moved to table the Southeast Development Area hearing indefinitely; seconded (seconder not identified). Result: passed, 6-1. No: Nick Richardson (Councilmember, District 6). 07:48:27
- Mike Karbassi (Councilmember, District 2) argued nothing had changed since a similar debate last December and that there is no political will or ability to sustain SEDA 07:47:01
- Mike Karbassi (Councilmember, District 2) moved to table the item indefinitely so it would not return 07:47:01
- A councilmember checked with the city attorney that a procedural motion needs no public comment 07:47:49
Adjournment in memory
The meeting was adjourned in memory of a trailblazing labor leader and civil rights activist who fought for farm workers. 07:49:35
Public comment
- No one spoke during the public comment period on the consent calendar, contested consent, and closed session.
- One remote speaker, called during the comment period for the eminent domain hearing, instead objected to consent item 2B (Chaffee Zoo parking lease) after it had passed. The speaker cited loss of Roeding Park green space near a low-income neighborhood, air quality from added parking, replacement of trees without regard to biodiversity, poor public outreach by the zoo, and the unclear source of construction money.
- The same remote speaker, during the Office zone text amendment hearing, said they still had not received a large-print hard copy of the agenda, called late printing a barrier for people with disabilities, and asked what the amendment changed.
- During unscheduled communication, two remote speakers urged the city to keep warming centers open all winter, including on rainy days, ahead of an expected El Niño season. One said the city's homeless response team, which the speaker called the HART team, had taken unhoused people's blankets in the past week. One thanked planning staff for infill housing work, and one congratulated election winners and thanked Miguel Arias (Councilmember, District 3) for eight years of service.
- One remote speaker commented on the workshop, saying they liked it.
- There was no public comment on the Southeast Development Area item, which was tabled by procedural motion.
What's next
- Water and wastewater rates: the Prop 218 public hearing is set for December 29, 2026 at 9:00 a.m. (agenda); city staff said it will be a special meeting. About 180,000 protest notices will be mailed, and staff said nine community meetings are planned.
- City staff said they would have a framework for a parkway-strip conversion program by the Prop 218 hearing, and would provide Miguel Arias (Councilmember, District 3) with total water and wastewater reserve figures and Brandon Vang (Councilmember, District 5) with the split of customers inside the city and in county islands.
- Miguel Arias (Councilmember, District 3) asked legal counsel to report back on whether the Shell well-contamination settlement is being applied as the council understood it.
- Items 2F (lease of agricultural land at the regional wastewater plant) and 2I (the Section 108 affordable housing loan application) were tabled to the November 12, 2026 meeting.
- Community Facilities District No. 9 Annexation No. 78 public hearing: December 3, 2026 at 9:20 a.m. (agenda).
- The Office zone text amendment bill was listed on the agenda for introduction; the transcript does not say when it returns for adoption.
- City staff said the city plans to demolish the old police headquarters and dispatch building once the new 9-1-1 center is complete, possibly after historic preservation review.
- The Southeast Development Area Specific Plan and its environmental report were tabled indefinitely.
- Veterans Day Parade: November 11 at 11:11 a.m., with free transportation from three pickup spots.
- Upcoming regular council meetings per the agenda: November 12 and December 3 and 17, 2026, and January 7, 2027.
Write to the City Council before its next meeting: clerk@fresno.gov or its comment form