· 22 items
City Council, Thursday, November 12
On the episode: Council: $2.75M labor-deal threshold, immigration limits on city property
This episode was produced with AI from the public recordings of the week's meetings. Links to the sources are in the show notes.
What happened
City Council Thursday, November 12
22 items
Agenda approval; PLA and immigration items moved back to consent
Before approving the agenda, the clerk read a correction to item 2B and listed items members had pulled for separate discussion (2B, 2F, 2Q, 2R, 2T). The council then voted to put 2B, the Project Labor Agreement amendment, and 2T, the policy on federal immigration enforcement on city property, back on the consent calendar, so both would be decided in the single consent vote rather than as separate contested items; both were still debated at length before that vote. 00:10:34
- A councilmember moved to move items 2B and 2T from contested consent back to the consent calendar; a councilmember seconded. Result: passed, 4-3. No: Miguel Arias (Councilmember, District 3), Brandon Vang (Councilmember, District 5), Nick Richardson (Councilmember, District 6). 00:15:50
- Motion to approve the agenda. Result: passed, 7-0. 00:18:01
- The city clerk read a correction to the 2B resolution adding authority for the city manager to make changes requested by the funding source 00:11:13
- A councilmember moved to return items 2B and 2T to the consent calendar 00:14:07
- Mike Karbassi (Councilmember, District 2) said he supports the motion but wanted it clear that backing 2T still means cooperating on people who committed violent offenses such as human trafficking 00:14:39
- A councilmember voted yes on the agenda while registering a no vote on items 2B and 2T 00:17:51
Proclamation: third anniversary of Casita Feliz
The council honored Casita Feliz, a Latine LGBTQ+ center in the Tower District, on its third anniversary. 00:18:06
Proclamation: Vocation Plus Connections Inc. (VPCI) Day
The council honored Vocation Plus Connections Inc., a program for people with developmental disabilities whose participants have been watering newly planted trees in Van Ness Village. 00:28:25
Proclamation: Kings Canyon Middle School girls' volleyball champions
The council honored the Kings Canyon Middle School varsity girls' volleyball team, which went 10-1 and won the Fresno Unified Division II championship. 00:34:38
Proclamation: Continued Service Day
The council proclaimed November 12 Continued Service Day, honoring military veterans who now work for the City of Fresno. 00:41:34
Proclamation: World Day of Remembrance for Road Traffic Victims
The council proclaimed November 14, 2026 World Day of Remembrance for road traffic victims; the proclamation as read says Fresno recorded 43 traffic deaths in 2025, including 26 pedestrians. 00:50:34
Recognition: ASE Blue Seal of Excellence for city vehicle maintenance shops
The city recognized the FAX maintenance division and the General Services fleet management division for earning the ASE Blue Seal of Excellence for technician certification. 01:01:40
Proclamation: day honoring a retiring local TV news anchor
The mayor and council proclaimed November 12 a day honoring a longtime ABC30 news anchor who is retiring at the end of the month. 01:09:33
Council, mayor and city manager reports
WaterElections and ballot measures
Members and the city manager gave announcements: upcoming Prop 218 meetings on water and sewer rates, holiday food giveaways, a water main break affecting county-island homes, a global email outage, and reactions to the Measure D and Measure S election results. 01:17:23
- A councilmember announced that Prop 218 informational meetings on proposed water and sewer rate increases are starting, with one Monday the 16th at 6 PM in the council chambers 01:17:43
- A councilmember announced Operation Gobble on Sunday, November 22 at Hoover High, with full Thanksgiving dinners for over 750 District 4 families and volunteers needed the day before 01:18:34
- A councilmember announced the District 5 turkey giveaway on Saturday, November 21 at Sunnyside High School 01:19:31
- A councilmember thanked his staff for coordinating a free shuttle for veterans and families to and from the Veterans Day parade 01:20:53
- A councilmember said he was disappointed that items were moved from contested back to consent, which would limit discussion from the dais 01:21:58
- A councilmember said Measure S appears unlikely to pass and credited Measure D with sparing the city from laying off about 200 workers starting in January 01:23:22
- City staff described a water line break near Clovis Avenue and Butler affecting county-island homes with no storm drains and septic tanks, and thanked city crews 01:24:52
- City staff said city crews had been on site for five days and that the aging line needs replacement 01:27:55
- A councilmember said the failure of Measure S will hit rural county communities hard, while the city avoids layoffs 01:29:25
- City staff announced a global Microsoft email outage affecting city email, with staff using Teams and text instead 01:31:20
Special tax annexation: Community Facilities District No. 17 (McKinley and Temperance)
Bonds and debtTaxes and fees
A hearing to annex the land in Final Tract Maps 6502 and 6549, north side of East McKinley Avenue east of North Temperance Avenue (District 7), into Community Facilities District No. 17 and levy a special tax on those properties starting in tax year 2026-2027, through resolutions, a mailed-ballot election and an ordinance. No one spoke during the hearing. 01:31:47
- A councilmember moved to approve the resolutions and ordinance. Result: passed, 7-0. 01:33:19
Special tax annexation: Community Facilities District No. 18 (McKinley and Temperance)
Bonds and debtTaxes and fees
A hearing to annex the same tract map area (Tract Maps 6502 and 6549) into Community Facilities District No. 18, levy a special tax starting in tax year 2026-2027, and record a special tax lien. No one spoke during the hearing. 01:33:22
- A councilmember moved to approve the resolutions and ordinance. Result: passed, 7-0. 01:34:15
Special tax annexation: Community Facilities District No. 11 (McKinley and Temperance)
Bonds and debtTaxes and fees
A hearing to annex the same tract map area into Community Facilities District No. 11 and levy a special tax there starting in tax year 2026-2027. No one spoke during the hearing. 01:34:18
- A councilmember moved to approve the resolutions and ordinance. Result: passed, 7-0. 01:35:14
- A councilmember remarked that these community facilities districts are a way of making development pay for itself 01:34:18
Rezone for 53-home gated subdivision at Copper Avenue and Portofino Drive
Development projectsZoning and plansHousing supply
A hearing on about 8.47 acres at the northeast corner of East Copper Avenue and North Portofino Drive (District 6). It changes the land from medium-low-density residential and community commercial to medium-density residential in the General Plan and Woodward Park Community Plan, and rezones it from RS-4 and CC to RS-5. It also approves a tentative map for 53 single-unit lots and a planned development permit that reduces setbacks and lot sizes, raises maximum lot coverage, and allows private gated streets. The package includes a mitigated negative declaration under CEQA. No one spoke during the hearing. 01:35:16
- Motion to approve the environmental finding, plan amendment, rezone, tract map and planned development permit (mover not identified). Result: passed, 7-0. 01:36:11
Project Labor Agreement renewal: threshold set at $2.75 million Item 2-B
Jobs and wagesContracts and purchasingStreets and public works
An amendment to the city's Project Labor Agreement with the building trades for city public works projects, sponsored by the administration with Nelson Esparza (Councilmember, District 7; Council President), Tyler Maxwell (Councilmember, District 4; Council Vice President) and Annalisa Perea (Councilmember, District 1). Under the agreement, union labor terms apply to city projects above a contract-value threshold. The current threshold is $1 million, and the administration negotiated $3.5 million with no escalator for another five years. Other negotiated changes: residents of county islands count as local hires, and the city-resident apprentice goal is set at 50%. The council approved it on consent with the threshold amended from the dais to $2,750,000. The item is subject to the mayor's veto, and the mayor urged the council to keep the negotiated $3.5 million. 01:36:24
▶ Hear it Bargaining over the union-labor threshold, live from the dais · 0:47
- A councilmember moved to approve the consent calendar with 2B amended to a $2,250,000 threshold (later offering $2,500,000); the seconder withdrew. Result: withdrawn. 03:22:07
- A councilmember moved to approve the consent calendar, excluding contested items, with item 2B amended to a $2,750,000 project threshold. Result: passed, 6-1. No: Nick Richardson (Councilmember, District 6). 03:33:04
- A councilmember proposed an amendment raising the threshold from $1,000,000 to $2,250,000 instead of the negotiated amount 01:36:38
- A councilmember said any change from what was negotiated would have to go back for approval and could return at the next meeting 01:37:41
- A councilmember asked for the rationale, noting the council had earlier sent the administration back to negotiate and was now renegotiating the number from the dais 01:39:05
- A councilmember thanked the building trades, credited labor for his election, and predicted the council would split the difference 02:56:53
- A councilmember rejected a caller's claim that the agreement amounts to wage theft 02:56:53
- An elected official said the administration spent a year negotiating a $3.5 million threshold with no escalator, the trades voted to approve it, and it should not be reopened from the dais 03:05:43
- An elected official said he would not want the agreement modified at the dais 03:05:43
- City staff said the $3.5 million figure came from data on the 59 projects covered so far, whose average contract was about $4.79 million 03:10:41
- City staff said the trades won counting county-island residents as city residents in exchange 03:11:41
- City staff urged the council to keep the $3.5 million threshold reached in good-faith negotiation 03:13:48
- A councilmember offered $2,750,000 as a compromise figure 03:15:13
- A councilmember said the staff report gives no rationale for any of the changes 03:16:55
- A councilmember argued that going from $1 million to $3.5 million is a 250% increase that inflation cannot explain 03:17:57
- A councilmember argued that a higher threshold means fewer city jobs for local union members, and offered $2.5 million 03:19:14
- A councilmember asked for a public commitment to support a veto override in exchange for the lower figure 03:20:44
- A councilmember withdrew the second from the $2.25 million motion 03:22:02
- A councilmember said he supports $2.75 million but is not guaranteeing a vote to override a veto 03:23:00
- A councilmember said he had asked the administration to count county-island residents as local hires, which was accepted 03:24:30
- A councilmember said he had asked the administration for a $2.5 million threshold 03:25:38
- A councilmember cited a left-turn signal project at Millbrook and Alluvial that cost about $400,000 years ago and now costs about $1.2 million 03:25:38
- A councilmember argued the agreement lacks consequences if local-hire and apprenticeship goals are missed 03:28:41
- City staff asked whether any amendment must also be agreed to by the building trades, and noted nods from the city attorneys 03:31:46
Policy restricting federal immigration enforcement on city property Item 2-T
Immigrants
A resolution sponsored by Annalisa Perea (Councilmember, District 1) and Nelson Esparza (Councilmember, District 7; Council President) that sets a policy restricting the use of city-owned or city-controlled property for federal civil immigration enforcement. It is a resolution, not an ordinance, and its sponsor said it states the council's intent, with implementation to be worked out with the city manager and city attorney. It passed in the consent vote; it is subject to the mayor's veto. 01:36:24
- A councilmember moved to approve the consent calendar, excluding contested items, with item 2B amended (2T approved as posted). Result: passed, 6-1. No: Nick Richardson (Councilmember, District 6). 03:33:04
- A councilmember said attendance at his district's community events dropped after federal immigration enforcement intensified in 2025, and hoped for a unanimous vote 02:54:37
- A councilmember said supporting the resolution was easy for him 02:55:44
- An elected official said police policy bars officers from immigration enforcement and from asking about status, and that the city does not share information with ICE 02:58:18
- An elected official said he raised concerns about ICE tactics in a call with the White House and the Department of Homeland Security that Tuesday 02:59:19
- An elected official asked what the consequences would be if ICE uses city property anyway 03:00:20
- A councilmember said the resolution states intent rather than law, and that implementation details, including consequences, will be worked out with the city manager and city attorney 03:00:48
- An elected official said armed police should not be expected to confront armed ICE agents, though putting the federal government on notice was understandable 03:02:06
- Mike Karbassi (Councilmember, District 2) called the item somewhat symbolic but said it sets the tone 03:07:13
- Mike Karbassi (Councilmember, District 2) said enforcement should focus on violent criminals rather than working people 03:08:18
- A councilmember said he voted no because moving the item back to consent removed the chance to add recording and reporting provisions 03:31:12
Eminent domain: easement at Shields Avenue and Fresno Street for Shields Avenue Trail
Biking and walkingStreets and public works
A hearing on a resolution of necessity authorizing eminent domain to acquire a permanent public street easement on part of a privately owned parcel at the southwest corner of East Shields Avenue and North Fresno Street (District 7), for the Shields Avenue Trail from Blackstone to Fresno. It requires five votes. No one spoke during the hearing. 05:23:05
- A councilmember moved to approve the resolution of necessity. Result: passed. 05:24:12
Eminent domain: easements at 3809 North Sherman Street for Blackstone Shields-Dakota project
Streets and public worksBiking and walking
A hearing on a resolution of necessity authorizing eminent domain for permanent street and pedestrian easements and a temporary construction easement on part of a privately owned parcel at 3809 North Sherman Street (District 4), for the Blackstone Shields-Dakota Affordable Housing and Sustainable Communities improvements project. It requires five votes. Staff said negotiations with the owners will continue. 05:24:12
- A councilmember moved to approve the resolution of necessity. Result: passed, 6-1. No: Miguel Arias (Councilmember, District 3). 05:31:04
- City staff said design is expected to be complete by January 2027 and the right-of-way phase by May 2027 05:27:35
- A councilmember asked whether the item could wait until December 3 05:28:05
- City staff said the project is funded by an AHSC grant with a March 2028 closeout deadline 05:28:31
- City staff said staff will keep negotiating with the property owners even if the resolution is approved 05:29:24
- A councilmember moved approval because the property is in District 4 05:29:48
- A councilmember called eminent domain a big step and urged staff to reach a negotiated resolution, saying projects should improve the neighborhood 05:30:00
Up to $130 million in lease revenue bonds for road paving and police building
Bonds and debtStreets and public works
In a joint meeting with the Fresno Joint Powers Financing Authority, the council approved issuing lease revenue bonds of up to $130 million to fund the Pave More Now road projects and improvements to the police department administration building, and amending the 2008 master facilities lease. City actions required five votes. Staff said the bonds include $100 million for paving, $8 million for the police building, $14 million in capitalized interest and about $1.7 million in issuance costs, about $124 million in total, with the $130 million cap allowing for market changes. 05:31:08
- A councilmember moved to approve the Joint Powers Financing Authority actions. Result: passed. 05:32:38
- Motion to approve the city's resolutions on the bond issuance and lease amendments (mover not identified). Result: passed, 7-0. 05:34:39
- City staff said the financing authority has three members: the mayor, the council president and the vice president 05:32:19
- A councilmember asked staff to break down the $130 million figure 05:32:56
- City staff said $100 million of bond proceeds go to Pave More Now, with $14 million of capitalized interest to bridge debt service until pension obligation bonds are paid off in 2029 05:33:05
- City staff said the $130 million is a not-to-exceed cap and the sale is planned for the first week of December 05:34:09
$10,500 for the senior hot meals program Item 2-F
Seniors and disabilityFood and public benefitsBudgets
A budget amendment (29th amendment to the annual appropriation resolution) adding $10,500 for the fiscal year 2027 Senior Hot Meals Program. It requires five votes. It was pulled from consent and approved without discussion. 05:35:23
- A councilmember moved to approve; a councilmember seconded. Result: passed, 7-0. 05:35:52Ayes: Nelson Esparza, Tyler Maxwell, Annalisa Perea, Mike Karbassi, Miguel Arias, Brandon Vang, Nick Richardson. Moved by Nick Richardson, seconded by Nelson Esparza. From the clerk's record
Veterans' preference in city contracting introduced Item 2-Q
Contracts and purchasingSmall business
An ordinance, sponsored by Nick Richardson (Councilmember, District 6), giving veteran-owned businesses (at least 50% owned by a veteran) a 5% preference on city purchases below the formal bid limit, which staff said is about $184,000, and on professional and service contracts. A preference means the city can pay more than the lowest bid. Local businesses already get a 5% preference, and a local veteran-owned firm would get 10%. Before the vote, members discussed limiting the veterans preference to Fresno-based veteran businesses. The bill was introduced, not yet adopted. 05:35:54
- A councilmember moved approval to introduce the ordinance, after a friendly amendment limiting the veterans preference to Fresno-based veteran businesses was accepted in discussion. Result: passed, 7-0. 05:50:45Ayes: Nelson Esparza, Tyler Maxwell, Annalisa Perea, Mike Karbassi, Miguel Arias, Brandon Vang, Nick Richardson. Moved by Nick Richardson, seconded by Tyler Maxwell. From the clerk's record
- A councilmember asked whether the city would be stuck awarding to a higher veteran bid over a lower non-veteran bid 05:37:03
- City staff explained that the city would add 5% to the non-veteran bid and then award to whoever is still lowest 05:37:32
- A councilmember said the veterans preference works the same way as the existing local preference 05:37:52
- A councilmember noted that taxpayers would pay more than the lowest bid for both local and veteran preferences 05:38:24
- City staff said state rules bar preferences based on sex, race or gender, but other categories may be allowed 05:40:25
- City staff said the local preference on large contracts is set in the city charter and can only be changed by a charter amendment 05:40:44
- City staff said the preference covers professional and service contracts and purchases under the formal bid limit, about $184,000 05:41:40
- A councilmember said self-certification requires proof of service such as a veteran ID or DD214, and excludes dishonorable discharges 05:42:20
- Annalisa Perea (Councilmember, District 1) asked whether the policy could favor out-of-area veteran firms and cost the city more 05:45:43
- City staff said a veteran-owned business is one at least 50% owned by a veteran 05:46:07
- A councilmember proposed a friendly amendment limiting the preference to City of Fresno veteran businesses, since Fresno taxpayers would pay the premium 05:47:41
- City staff reported that about 67 veteran-owned businesses are currently registered 05:51:03
License plate reader rules tabled to December 3 Item 2-R
Surveillance technologyPolicing
A proposed ordinance, sponsored by Nick Richardson (Councilmember, District 6), setting rules for the Fresno Police Department's automated license plate recognition program. It comes after reports, raised by speakers, of an officer misusing Flock cameras and outside agencies accessing city data; the mayor said Flock lacks safeguards to keep data from being shared, and that the city will not renew its Flock contract. The council tabled the bill to its next regular meeting, December 3, and a two-member ad hoc committee was set up to work on it. The sponsor noted that the cameras stay in use in the meantime. 05:51:10
▶ Hear it Tabling plate-reader rules means the cameras keep running · 1:08
- A councilmember moved to table the bill to the next regular meeting, December 3; a councilmember seconded. Result: continued, 7-0. 05:56:32
- An elected official said the city will not renew its Flock contract because Flock lacks safeguards against data sharing, but other vendors such as one used for 15 years have them 03:02:06
- An elected official read a police report of a carjacking the night before in which the stolen car was located with help from the plate-reader system 03:04:15
- A councilmember said the subject needs law enforcement, IT and constitutional experts, noted the draft exempts other departments, and moved to table it for a council workshop 05:52:24
- A councilmember warned that while the item is tabled the cameras remain in use without council oversight, and asked colleagues to join a working group 05:53:09
- A councilmember asked the body to appoint the ad hoc committee now rather than wait for the new council 05:54:10
- A councilmember agreed to take part and said the council faces a tough conversation about whether to keep plate readers at all 05:55:06
- A councilmember approved a two-member ad hoc committee 05:55:21
Closed session: direction on Building Healthy Communities litigation Item 5-B
Lawsuits and settlements
The council met in closed session on labor negotiations with all city bargaining units (5A), four existing or anticipated litigation matters (5C–5F), and the case pairing the City of Fresno and Fresno Building Healthy Communities (PARCS Department) (5B). It reported out only on 5B, giving the city attorney direction that will be disclosed later. 06:05:34
- Closed-session vote giving the city attorney direction on item 5B. Result: passed, 7-0. 08:18:45
Public comment
- About 16 speakers, in the chamber and on Zoom, urged approval of item 2T restricting immigration enforcement on city property. Many came from immigrant-rights and advocacy groups. They described families afraid to send children to school, go to work, visit parks or clinics, and one asked the mayor not to veto it. One Zoom caller opposed it as pandering.
- Six speakers addressed the Project Labor Agreement (2B). Three, aligned with non-union contractors, opposed renewal or asked for a delay and a much higher threshold. One of them cited the city's February 2026 local-hire summary: 34% of journey-level hours against a 50% goal, 38% of apprentice hours against 55%, and 0% from new local apprentices against 30%. Another said their group would file a public records request comparing PLA and non-PLA bids. A union representative and a union contractor opposed raising the $1 million threshold. The building trades' negotiator asked the council to honor the negotiated $3.5 million figure rather than negotiate from the dais.
- About ten speakers addressed the license plate reader rules (2R). Seven opposed the cameras or asked to table the item, citing reports of an officer misusing Flock cameras and outside agencies accessing city data, a public records request for Flock data they said had been pending 82 days, and a planned new vendor contract in December. Three supported keeping plate readers; one said crime in his neighborhood dropped, and others cited a problem property nearby and cases they said the cameras helped solve.
- One speaker questioned the $1,000 sale of 4.86 acres to the Housing Authority (2H). They said the units would serve households up to 60% of area median income rather than people experiencing homelessness, called for social housing, and asked whether other proposals were considered.
- One speaker thanked the city for the Youth Jobs Corps program and the senior meals funding.
- Three speakers in unscheduled communication: one described car break-ins and public urination in the Tower District and asked for portable toilets and on-site security; one thanked the council for tabling 2R and offered to collaborate; one with security-industry experience urged the city to evaluate an alternative plate-reader vendor with safeguards and outside auditing.
What's next
- License plate reader ordinance (2R) returns at the December 3, 2026 regular meeting; a two-member ad hoc committee of a councilmember (the sponsor) and Mike Karbassi (Councilmember, District 2) is to work on it in the meantime.
- Project Labor Agreement (2B): approved at a $2,750,000 threshold rather than the negotiated $3.5 million. It is subject to the mayor's veto, and the dais discussion suggested the change may need the building trades' agreement and could come back.
- Veterans' preference ordinance (2Q) was introduced; adoption comes at a later meeting not specified.
- Lease revenue bond sale of up to $130 million is planned for the first week of December, according to finance staff.
- Blackstone Shields-Dakota project: negotiations with the property owners continue; staff target design by January 2027, right-of-way by May 2027, with an AHSC funding deadline of March 2028.
- Hearings set: CFD No. 9 Annexation No. 81 on December 3, 2026 at 9:10 a.m.; CFD No. 9 Annexation No. 80 on December 17, 2026 at 9:20 a.m. (agenda).
- Prop 218 informational meetings on water and sewer rates: Monday the 16th at 6 PM in council chambers, Tuesday December 15 at Gaston Middle School, and Wednesday December 16 at Fresno High, per a councilmember.
- The mayor said the city will not renew its Flock camera contract; speakers referred to a plate-reader contract expected in December.
- Closed-session direction on item 5B will be disclosed later, according to the closed-session report.
- Upcoming council meetings: December 3 and December 17, 2026, and January 7, 2027 (agenda).
Write to the City Council before its next meeting: clerk@fresno.gov or its comment form